Topic: HUMAN SEMANTICS
Context Dependence and Compositionality
Francis Jeffry Pelletier
Source: Language & Mind
Some utterances of sentences such as `Every student failed the midterm exam' and `There is no beer' are widely held to be true in a conversation despite the facts that not every student in the world failed the midterm exam and that there is, in fact, some beer somewhere. For instance, the speaker might be talking about some particular course, or about his refrigerator. Stanley and Szab?-- (in Mind and Language v. 15, 2000) consider many different approaches to how contextual information might give meaning to these `restricted quantifier domains', and find all of them but one wanting. The present paper argues that their considerations against one of these other theories, considerations that turn on notions of compositionality, are incorrect.
Download
Posted by Tony Marmo
at 00:01 BST
Updated: Wednesday, 22 September 2004 20:13 BST